
Bleakness was inevitable, was it not? Ever since their bombastic debut in 2008, there was a constant anticipation for Vampire Weekend to slowly develop into one of the most notable pop bands of this century. In five years, the playful college kids of Vampire Weekend have naturally matured not only in terms of songwriting but also in terms of musical aspiration. To put it simply, Vampire Weekend have been a consistently great band but through the year, the reasons for their greatness have changed significantly. They no longer rely on fun, afro-pop inspired sneer to win people over. On their third album Modern Vampires of the City, the group has developed their music into something gorgeously conventional while gaining a new form of lyrical sincerity and reflection.
Modern Vampires is their most serious album yet, and with this depth comes a very fitting ear for sound. Indeed, the most obvious thing about this album is the production. There is absolutely no hiding from the fact that Modern Vampires is one of the nicest sounding indie pop albums made in recent memory; every song is constructed with an exceptional emphasis on beauty where the sound blossoms into a very warm sense of distance. All the arrangements on the record are absolutely spot-on with the frequently gut-wrenching vocal performances from Ezra Koenig teaming up with the distorted rhythms to form huge crescendos, clashing magnificently when placed next to the subtle strings and soft pianos. Vampire Weekend has always taken influences from genres that exist outside of pop music and although they don’t stop doing that here, the world music influences which shined very brightly through the group’s first two records are sacrificed for a much more nonchalant flavor of classical music. String sections play a huge part on songs like ‘Everlasting Arms’ where the masterful ingenuity turns into an absolute wonder. Throughout this album you get the sense of a band who knows exactly what they are doing in terms of seducing the listener, because the attention to detail in every single note is completely captivating.
The melodic aspect of this album is also good, but it sometimes suffers from a sense of oversimplification. From the very first track (‘Obvious Bicycle’) there is a nagging notion that much of what you are hearing is borrowed, as the gospel like choral progression is something you can find in countless traditional songs. ‘Obvious Bicycle’ is a somewhat underwhelming start to the record and the improvement is only slight with the pleasant but pedestrian successor ‘Unbelievers’. Tracks like these focus on aura and concept over actual substance and it is a mindset that this record suffers from, especially during its less aesthetically flattering moments. However, a great chunk of this album contains some of the most moving and remarkable work the band has ever done. For example, ‘Step’ makes use of incredibly humble dynamics to form a track that is emotionally staggering, displaying warm potency through the flawless placement of every single idea. It is a soft song that blows everything out of the water, a weirdly functional juxtaposition to the following track ‘Diane Young’ which recalls the energy of Buddy Holly to make potentially the most aggressive thing in Vampire Weekend’s catalogue (except for maybe ‘Cousins’). ‘Don’t Lie’ and ‘Hannah Hunt’ are both ballads, with the former being sharper and the latter taking a hushed but climatically gut-wrenching approach that Vampire Weekend seem to do very well. ‘Everlasting Arms’ is the most digestible and striking song on the album while ‘Hudson’ is easily the darkest sounding song Vampire Weekend has ever written. Ironically, the stickiest songs on the album (‘Finger Back’ and ‘Worship You’) are also the most haggard and stale because they are the moments where Vampire Weekend let go of their musical subtlety and go for a much more obnoxious form of infection. Apart from a few let downs, Modern Vampires is an entertaining batch of songs that are taken to the next level by flawless execution.
The last thing worth mentioning about this album is its lyrics; Modern Vampires is easily the most profound and earnest of all their records. Koenig’s sharp poetic tongue still plays a huge part because listening to this album exposes you to some phenomenally well-written wordplay. However, the thematic side of the album can be picked up just by a casual glance. Koenig leaves his ideas on full display and the most prominent one on here is definitely religion. There is fine line between being introspective and being preachy and although Vampire Weekend usually stay on the good side of that line, tracks like ‘Obvious Bicycle’ and ‘Worship You’ might be a bit more explicit than they need to be. However, the times when Koenig gets it right are super thought-provoking. ‘Unbelievers’ takes a very strong look at the anticlimax that is Christian faith (“I’m not excited but should I be/is this the fate that half of the world has planned for me”) while ‘Everlasting Arms’ takes a similar pessimistic glance on the same topic (“oh I was born to live without you but I’m never gonna understand”). Much of this album deals with sadness but the most heartbreaking song on the album is ‘Ya Hey’, which serves as a centerpiece thanks to its fascinating depth and powerful progression. It sees Koenig in an existential crisis, dealing with his loss of faith in what almost feels like an resignation directed at God (“America don’t love you/so I could never love you/in spite of everything”). This is this type of power that makes Modern Vampires such a great album, although there seems to be a lack of dimension and originality holding it back from something more.
High Points: ‘Step’, ‘Diane Young’, ‘Don’t Lie’, ‘Hannah Hunt’, ‘Everlasting Arms’, ‘Ya Hey’
Low Points: ‘Obvious Bicycle’, ‘Finger Back’, ‘Worship You’
7.5/10